Reflections · Families
Family business and family trusts: keeping the family whole

The best family businesses and family trusts are deliberate about governance — and I mean governance of the relationships, not only of the money. Most shareholders' agreements and trust deeds are drafted to settle ownership, tax and who decides. They can be designed to do more: to foster good relations, educate the next generation and recognise achievement. The families I think do this best write those goals into the documents, then hold the meetings and keep the promises the documents describe — for years after the lawyers have gone home.
A companion piece. This Reflection covers the family side of a family business or trust. Its companion on lawyercorporation.ca, family trust governance: designing documents beyond the money, covers the legal structures. I write both because I am a relationship therapist and a business lawyer, and in family enterprises the two kinds of problem tend to arrive together.
The documents are usually too narrow
When a family enterprise comes apart, people usually blame the paperwork. Often the paperwork did exactly what it was drafted to do. It settled who owns what and who decides — and nothing about how the family would stay connected to each other or to what they own.
A family meeting about dividends can turn, within minutes, into a conversation about who was trusted as a teenager and who was not. Most shareholders' agreements say nothing about that kind of conversation. They could. A document that requires regular family meetings, sets out how decisions will be explained, and commits the family to educating its next generation gives everyone a structure for the hard conversations before they happen badly.
Family-business scholars Ludo Van der Heyden, Christine Blondel and Randel Carlock found that families judge fairness by three different yardsticks — need, merit and equality — and that much of the conflict in family firms comes from people using different yardsticks without knowing it (Fair Process: Striving for Justice in Family Firms). A sibling who runs the company tends to think about merit; one who lives away and owns the same shares, about equality; a parent, often about need. Each can be fair by their own measure and still be in conflict with the others.
Is it fair to treat every child equally?
Many founders try to solve this by treating every child identically: equal shares, equal votes, equal everything. It feels safe. In my experience it often postpones the conflict rather than preventing it, because the business itself is rarely equal — one child carries it and the others benefit from it.
Van der Heyden and his colleagues also found that people can accept a decision they disagree with when they believe the process was fair: nobody was surprised, everyone saw the same information, the reasons were explained, and they had a real chance to be heard. A fair process asks the founder to say out loud why the business is going to one child, and to stay in the room while the others react.
What the founder's silence costs
Founders often keep succession to themselves. Sometimes it is protectiveness; often it is that they have not decided, and saying so feels like weakness.
The cost lands on the next generation. PwC's Canadian research found that of family businesses planning to pass on management or ownership, 27% had not involved the next generation in preparing for it (PwC Canada). Owners feel the gap too: in a 2021 Family Enterprise Foundation survey, about half of Canadian family business owners said they were concerned the next generation is not ready or willing to take over (Family Enterprise Foundation). A child who first learns their role from a lawyer's letter after a death has no one left to ask why.
A family trust can make this worse without anyone intending it. The trustees decide who receives what; the beneficiaries have no vote. If the founder never explained what they hoped for — and never told the beneficiaries the trust existed, or why — the trustees' decisions will feel arbitrary to the people living with them. A letter of wishes, written by the founder in their own voice and shared with the family, can tell the beneficiaries why — which the deed on its own rarely does.
What I see go wrong
Two things, mostly. Families fight, and the relationships break down — sometimes over a decision, more often over years of decisions nobody explained. And the next generation is stunted by the wealth itself. A young adult who has never had to earn, choose or be accountable, and who knows a trust will cover the gap, can reach forty without finding out what they are capable of.
A widely cited study by the Williams Group consultancy, drawn from interviews with 3,250 families, attributed about 60% of failed wealth transitions to a breakdown of trust and communication and another 25% to heirs who were not prepared. It is a consultancy study rather than peer-reviewed research, so I treat the exact numbers with caution; the direction matches what I see (CPABC on the Williams Group findings).
Neither problem shows up in a valuation or a tax plan. Both can be addressed in the governance documents, if someone thinks to put them there. (The everyday version of this — siblings, spouses and parents working side by side — is in why being in business with family is so hard.)
Governance as a relationship practice
The usual mistake is to treat governance as something you set up and then stop thinking about. Everyone signs, and nobody talks about it again until there is a crisis. The other mistake is to think too small — to treat the whole thing as a tax and ownership exercise.
Thinking bigger means building goals into the documents that a tax adviser would never ask about:
- Fostering relationships. A regular family meeting that is not a board meeting — where people who do not work in the business still have a voice, and where in-laws are welcomed rather than managed.
- Educating. Teaching the next generation what it means to own something together: how to read the numbers, how decisions get made, what the trust is for. Education is also how a young adult learns they are trusted.
- Rewarding. Recognising contribution that is not on a payroll — the sibling who chairs the family council, the cousin who keeps the history, the parent who holds everyone together at holidays.
In my experience, this is what keeps a fourth-generation shareholder from selling to a stranger because they never felt part of the thing they owned.
Questions for a first family meeting
These are the questions I would want a family to answer together before anyone drafts or redrafts a document:
- What do we want this business or trust to do for the family, beyond the money?
- What does “fair” mean to each of us — equal, by need, or by contribution?
- Who works in the business, and what should they need before they do?
- What should the next generation learn, and who will teach them?
- How will we recognise contributions that are not on a payroll?
- How will decisions be explained to the people they affect?
- Where do in-laws fit?
- When we disagree, what will we do before anyone calls a lawyer?
- How often will we meet, and who is responsible for calling the meeting?
What changes in the room
In couples therapy, an argument about money or chores is often an argument about respect and recognition. Family enterprises work the same way, with old roles added. Adult siblings fall back into the parts they played as children. Founders who built something alone find it hard to share authority with people they still see as kids.
It helps to slow down and understand the pattern before trying to fix it — to see what each person is protecting and why, before anyone is asked to compromise. Forcing agreement too early tends to produce documents people sign and then quietly resent.
For how those structures can be drafted to carry relational goals — shareholders' agreements, family charters, trust deeds, letters of wishes and the 21-year rule — see the companion article on lawyercorporation.ca, family trust governance: designing documents beyond the money. If the family wants an adviser trained across law, tax and family dynamics, Family Enterprise Canada keeps a directory of Family Enterprise Advisors (FEA). The families whose structures hold are usually the ones whose documents were designed for the relationships as well as the money, and who kept using them. If you would like to talk it through, a free fifteen-minute call is a reasonable place to start.
Common questions
Why do family businesses fall apart?
Often not because of the business itself but because of unspoken disagreements about fairness, roles and recognition. Documents drafted only for ownership and tax leave those disagreements with nowhere to go; documents designed to require meetings, explain decisions and support education give the family a place to work them out.
Is it fair to leave the family business to one child?
It can be, if the reasons are explained and the other children are treated fairly in other ways. Families usually cope better with unequal outcomes when the process was open and everyone had a chance to be heard.
What is a family meeting in a family business?
A regular gathering of the owning family, separate from board meetings, where family members, including those who do not work in the business, discuss values, plans, education and concerns.
How do you talk to adult children about a family trust?
Plainly and early. Explain that the trust exists, what it is for, who the trustees are and what you hope for. A written letter of wishes, shared with the family, helps the trustees and the beneficiaries understand your intentions.
Can family wealth hold the next generation back?
It can. A young adult who has never had to earn, choose or be accountable may not find out what they are capable of. Education, expectations and recognition of real achievement, built into the family's governance, are what usually prevent that.
Can therapy help a family business?
It can help family members understand the patterns behind recurring conflicts and talk about fairness, roles and succession without the conversation collapsing. It works alongside, not instead of, legal and financial advice.
How should in-laws be included in a family business?
Most families do better with a clear, written policy on whether in-laws can work in the business or own shares, combined with real welcome at family meetings. Ambiguity is usually what causes resentment.
A note: This article is general information, not therapy or a substitute for it. If you're in crisis or need urgent help, please call or text 9-8-8 (Suicide Crisis Helpline) or call 9-1-1.